Friday, December 09, 2005

Transcorp: Messiah or another White Elephant.

This is my edited response to this topic on Nairaland.com (a Nigerian forum).

Transcorp can never and will never pull Nigeria out of the economic mess she has been wallowing in for years.

I see this Transcorp thing as a big way of deceiving Nigerians into believing that an economic Messiah has come. When flamboyant people whose motive in life is all about how they can increase their own net-worth teamed together to form a mega-corporation, what you can/must expect is nothing but a big failure.

Nigeria does not need a big corporation to get out of the economic quagmire she’s in right now. What we need is/are SMEs and unflinching support from the government. The US economy is buoyant because they give qualitative support to their SMEs, they value them more than corporations like Microsoft, IBM and Boeing.

SMEs have the potentials of creating more jobs in many regions of a country than any corporation, a small SME also do have the potentials of becoming a big player in her own sector too; Microsoft, IBM, Dell etc are classical examples.

What those founders of Transcorp are trying to do is to compete with foreign multinationals, they will fail woefully because they don’t have what it takes to match these people. Though they may have the financial and political muscle, Transcorp does not have a veritable original economic, development and innovative blueprint to become a world-class player overnight like they planned to.

What Transcorp has succeeded in doing to date is buying lucrative and already money spinning companies like Nicon Hilton, I wonder where the much touted new jobs will be created from when they are buying already running companies. I think they should have aptly call themselves “NigeriaWeAreBuying Corp, (NWAB Corp)”

Mega corporations are not the saviour of any nation’s economy because those that run them are mostly people that are out of sync with what’s obtainable on the street. Enron, Worldcom are veritable examples.

I hope Transcorp will not be just one of those SMEs killers here in Nigeria. Another important fear of mine is that some unscrupulous politicians will even use the company as a front to invest their stolen billions since Baba OBJ has now made London and Swiss banks a danger zone for them, (Bravo Balogun).

When the NSE DG is also a director and one of the “owner” of Transcorp, I wonder how she will be able to sanction the company (Transcorp) when they violate set standards (if there’s any) of NSE.

Meanwhile if you don’t know, Transcorp is owned by “sons and daughter of Mr. President” (that’s what Stella Obasanjo called most of the core members). For a start where did they get the money with which they bought NICON Hilton from?

Anyway, time will tell if Transcorp is a blessing or a curse.

7 Comments:

At 7:17 AM, Blogger Imnakoya said...

Welcome back to the blogosphere Jof-view. I have my reservations about Transcorp, particularly on how the directors were hand-picked by the president.

Just like you said: time- the best teacher, will surely indicate if this was a smart move.

I guess by your statement that you are not open to the idea of buying Transcorp stocks when it become available, eh?

 
At 9:37 AM, Blogger jof_views said...

Sure i will not buy it because it was meant for the super-rich, not the average Nigerian. A guy on Nairaland.com said they did private placement early this year (2005) and that there's a minimum amount that you can invest.

I think those guys are starting Nigeria's version of Berkshire Hathway and Carlyle Group.

 
At 12:20 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I've just discovered that the DG of the Nigerian Stosk Exchange is also the Chairman of Transcorp. Talk about conflict of interest!

 
At 10:32 PM, Blogger Imnakoya said...

"...private placement early this year (2005) and that there's a minimum amount that you can invest", this is interetsing, I will investigate further.


Is there a law that say the DG of the Stock Exchange can't be chairman to a private company?

 
At 9:21 AM, Blogger jof_views said...

Is there a law that say the DG of the Stock Exchange can't be chairman to a private company?


I don't know if it's against the law for her to head a company, but it's quite glaring that there will be a conflict of interest. Her heading a company does not create a level playing field for all other companies in the stock market.

 
At 1:47 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I will buy transcorp shares anyday. Lets give the guys a chance. OBJ has never had my support in most of his deeds, but for this one...he might get it right. Lets examine some of the raised issues

...."I see this Transcorp thing as a big way of deceiving Nigerians into believing that an economic Messiah has come. When flamboyant people whose motive in life is all about how they can increase their own net-worth teamed together to form a mega-corporation, what you can/must expect is nothing but a big failure"

...The guys handpicked by the government are credible leaders in thier different spheres, tested and trusted guys that have never really been associated with failure of anykind.What OBJ has tasked them to do is set up Transcorp. They wont run Transcorp. That is why Fola Adeola was recruited as GMD...see to the day to day affairs of Transcorp.

...."What Transcorp has succeeded in doing to date is buying lucrative and already money spinning companies like Nicon Hilton, I wonder where the much touted new jobs will be created from when they are buying already running companies. I think they should have aptly call themselves “NigeriaWeAreBuying Corp, (NWAB Corp)”

... First they havent bought NICON for buyin sakes. If you go through thier prospectus, they needed a one shop centre and NICON fits that. In the coming months NICON will be revamped.

..."Sure i will not buy it because it was meant for the super-rich, not the average Nigerian. A guy on Nairaland.com said they did private placement early this year (2005) and that there's a minimum amount that you can invest.

... You are quite right. Most private placements are meant for those that can afford it. Transcorp has said this is only the first phase of thier capital drive. Q1 2006, they will be going to the market with an IPO of N60 billion. Then everybody can have a share of the dream...

...Now a little more on Fola Adeola, the man who has been saddled with running Transcorp. This is somebody that formed GTBank, ran successfully for 12years, resigned without pressures after he saw the bank to it's present hieght of one of the best banks in the subregion. That is a trac record of efficient start ups. If he did it with GTBank, he might as well be tested on a bigger juicier project....TRANSCORP.

...I agree with this forum, lets wait and see...

 
At 2:56 PM, Blogger BEN HISTOPATHOLOGY LECTURES said...

Yes. I believe transcorps will realize its mission. The problems it is having now is not isolated. Nokia had that initial pessimistic attitude by the finish when it was a start up.
Agreed. Transcorps cannot achieve its megacorporation status immediately. It is just a start up company. It's vision is enviable and first of its kind in Nigeria.

Investment is a risk. The only way to banish poverty is to acquire savings and investment skills over a long time. Transcorps gives Nigerian youths the opportunity to make it in Nigeria through calculated investment.
The reasons for my optimism is not far fetched. Let us consider the business model to invest in emerging markets in Nigeria such as Agriculture,Agroprocessing, film industry, telecommunications, power, oil and gas including tourism.

The promoters are Nigerias tested and proven investors whose names is not worth mentioning here again.
In America, investors fall over themselves to follow the investment decisions of Warren Buffet. Let's copy such attitude from them and put our moneys where those who have made it in Nigeria put theirs. By so doing, it is guaranteed that you too will soon be in their class instead of complaining about their successes or just displaying sheer envy.

Benard Solomon
http://nigerianstockmarketsecrets.blogspot.com

 

Post a Comment

<< Home